Germany and the UK Prepare for Peak Oil

Posted by Jeff Rubin on September 15th, 2010 under SmallerWorldTags: , , ,  • 8 Comments

Why are the folks at the Bundeswehr Transformation Centre, a German military think-tank, already planning for peak oil? Probably for the same reason the British Department of Energy, in concert with the Bank of England and the British Department of Defense, has ordered similar—and equally secret—studies on its impact.

Despite repeated government assurances to the contrary, the global oil supply doesn’t seem to be growing much anymore. In fact, the Bundeswehr Centre study says that oil production may peak this year.

Most people judge peak oil concerns by the prevailing oil price. That prices have plunged from their triple-digit perch is proof enough to them that we need not worry about any imminent peak.

What they forget is where we’re coming from. The deepest global recession in the entire post-war period can cut oil prices lots of slack while demand is contracting; peak oil isn’t a problem if the economy it powers is shrinking. For the first time since 1983, world oil demand fell last year, bringing oil prices tumbling down. But recessions, even the deepest, only last so long.

The first thing you notice about a recovering economy is that it starts burning more fuel. The second is that oil prices are suddenly rising again.

Those prices are already twice as high as their lows during the recession and already at levels that, three years ago, would have been all-time highs. And that’s with the economies of the traditionally large oil-consuming countries in the world, like the 19-million-barrel-a-day US economy, still miles below their pre-recession peaks.

So while oil production may not have peaked in a geological sense, it may already have done so in a more important economic sense. Geologically, production can be boosted by accessing ever more costly and environmentally problematic sources of non-conventional supply, like tar sands. But as we have seen from the last recession, the global economy can’t run on the prices needed to bring that oil out of the ground.

The German study paints a bleak picture of the post-peak world: political power quickly shifts from major oil-consuming economies to major oil-producing economies. Less and less oil is traded on the open market, while more and more is traded between nation states, with national oil companies entering into long-term supply agreements that are tied to broader political and military considerations. And military alliances coalesce around the security of energy supply, rather than between countries with shared political or economic principles.

Perhaps these are the contours of the post-peak world. But military strategists shouldn’t underestimate the power of triple-digit oil prices to change the nature of our economies and, hence, our dependence on the fuel.

Nevertheless, it’s reassuring to know that at least some of our governments are thinking about peak oil, despite the fact that they still feel they must hide their concerns from their voters.

Share
  • Jpatrickdoyle

    USE OF THE CHATTANOOGA PROCESS (CP) TO PRODUCE 2,000,000
    BBL/DAY OF HIGH GRADE OIL FROM KENTUCKY SHALE

    The Chattanooga Process provides a technically simple, industrially proven and environmentally friendly approach to the extraction of oil from SE Kentucky oil shale. The mining, land reclamation and processing of oil shale will be conducted employing the following major considerations to ensure minimal disturbance of the landscape and environmental safety while at the same time economically producing a high quality, low sulfur product oil.

    1) THE PROJECT WILL INCLUDE COMPLETE AND FAR SUPERIOR LAND RECLAMATION, CONCURRENT WITH MINING AND PROCESSING.

    2) ALL MINING AND ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT WILL BE IDENTIFIED. SHALE RECEIVING AND PROCESSING AT THE PROCESS PLANT IS EXCLUDED FROM THIS REPORT.

    3) INCLUDED IN THE COST ESTIMATE WILL BE PROVISIONS FOR ITEMS SUCH AS GREEN FARM CROPS, TREES, GRASS, ROADS AND TRAILS IN THE RECLAMATION AREA.

    4) ALL MINING, BACKHAULING AND DUMPING, LEVELING OF SPENT SHALE AND RECLAIMING OVERBURDEN THAT WILL BE BANKED, WILL BE THOROUGHLY WATER SPRAYED. TRUCKS AND OTHER EQUIPMENT WILL HAVE ON BOARD WATER TANKS AND SPRAY EQUIPMENT.

    5) TRUCKS WILL AVERAGE 4 MILES ROUND TRIP, PLUS DRIVE TO SPENT SHALE HOPPER FOR BACKHAUL OF 105% OF RAW FEED VOLUME. ADDITIONAL 5% OF TRUCK CAPACITY IS REQUIRED DUE TO SWELLING OF SHALE BY GRINDING TO 80 MESH AVG SIZE.

    6) ORGANICS AND KEROGEN IN RAW SHALE WILL BE VAPORIZED IN THE CHATTANOOGA REACTOR LEAVING THE SAME VOLUME OF SPENT SOLIDS.

    7) PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF NEW ALBANY HIGHER GRADE SHALE:

    a) BULK DENSITY: 123 LBS/CU. FT
    b) MOISTURE: 4.0 %
    c) KEROGEN: FISCHER ASSAY OF 15 GAL/TON
    d) THE CP PRODUCES 200% OF FISCHER ASSAY. IT IS EXPECTED THAT THE COMMERCIAL PROJECT WILL YIELD AT LEAST 25 GAL/TON OF LIQUID PRODUCT OIL.

    8) DEPOSIT PROFILE: 40 BILLION TONS OF SHALE AT 17 SITES (EACH WITH TWO 60,000 BBL/DAY PLANTS), 100 MILES BY 150 MILES AREA IN SE KENTUCKY. AVERAGE RATIO OF OVERBURDEN TO SHALE IS ESTIMATED TO BE 2.5 TO 1.

    9) DEPOSIT IS PROVEN BY EXTENSIVE CORE DRILLING INFORMATION OF THE ENTIRE AREA.

    10) START-UP EQUIPMENT: MINING WILL COMMENCE ONE YEAR BEFORE PROCESS PLANT START-UP. THE START-UP OF MINING CAN FAST TRACK EQUIPMENT DELIVERY ONE YEAR BEFORE PROCESS PLANT START-UP. BOTH OVERBURDEN AND SHALE MINED IN FIRST YEAR CLEARS ONE SQUARE MILE OF MATERIAL FOR SITE PREPARATION, ROADS, ETC.

    11) START-UP WILL BE COMPLETED AT TIME OF FULL SCALE MINING. ALLSTART-UP COSTS WILL BE CAPITALIZED AND NOT EXPENSED AND ARE INCLUDED IN THE $2.6 BILLION COST ESTIMATE PER UNIT.

    12) THE CO2 PRODUCED BY THE TOTAL PROJECT IS ESTIMATED TO BE 150 LBS/BBL OF 30-32O API LOW SULFUR OIL (AFTER CREDIT APPLIED FOR SEQUESTRATION AND POWER GENERATION). IMPORTED 28O API HIGHER SULFUR OIL HAS A TOTAL ON SITE CO2 PRODUCTION OR EQUIVALENT METHANE VENTED EQUAL TO 400 LBS CO2 / BBL OF OIL SHIPPED VIA TANKERS.

    13) A MINING AND PROCESSING PLANT USING 100,000 TONS OF KENTUCKY SHALE WOULD PRODUCE 60,000 BBL/DAY OF CRUDE OIL. THE NEW ALBANY DEPOSIT IN SE KENTUCKY HAS AT LEAST 45 BILLION TONS OF HIGH GRADE SHALE WHICH WOULD BE SUFFICIENT FOR PRODUCING 2,000,000 BBL/DAY OF CP HIGH GRADE OIL FOR 40 YEARS. IT WOULD REDUCE THE USA BALANCE OF PAYMENTS BY $42 BILLION PER YEAR, THEREBY REDUCING DEPENDENCE ON IMPORTED OIL BY 20%.

    14) ABOUT $90 BILLION IN 2010 DOLLARS WILL BE REQUIRED TO BUILD 2,000,000 BBL/DAY CAPACITY IN SE KENTUCKY OVER A SIX YEAR PERIOD. ABOUT 250,000 JOBS WILL BE CREATED. SE KENTUCKY UNEMPLOYMENT IS 20% TODAY.

    15) THE SE KENTUCKY LAND IS NOT GOOD FOR FARMING TODAY, BUT AFTER RECLAMATION WITH NON-LEACHING SHALE AND REPLACING BANKED OVERBURDEN, IT WILL BE SUITABLE FOR ALL USES

    16) THE PROCESS DOES NOT REQUIRE SIGNIFICANT WATER AND PRODUCES NO WASTE WATER DISCHARGE.

    17) THE TOTAL CASH COST OF HIGH GRADE, LOW SULFUR OIL FROM SE KENTUCKY SHALE, INCLUDING MINING, WOULD BE $25/BBL WITH THEUSE OF CLEAN, GREEN NATURAL GAS FOR THE ONLY EXTERNAL SOURCE OF ENERGY.

    18) THE CP PRODUCES A SMALL AMOUNT OF CO2 THROUGH THE USE OF CLEAN NATURAL GAS IN SOME AUXILIARY OPERATIONS, HOWEVER A SIGNIFICANT PORTION OF THIS COULD BE SEQUESTERED AND USED BENEFICIALLY IN CERTAIN APPLICATIONS SUCH AS ENHANCED OIL RECOVERY IN SOME OF KENTUCKY’S DEPLETED OIL FIELDS. THIS BENEFICIAL USE IS VERY COMMON TO THE OIL INDUSTRY.

    19) PRODUCTION OF 2,000,000 BBL/DAY OF OIL FROM SE KENTUCKY OIL SHALE WOULD REQUIRE 1.5 BILLION CU. FT. OF CLEAN NATURAL GAS. THIS WOULD BE SUPPLIED BY TEXAS GAS TRANSMISSION VIA A 200 MILE PIPELINE FROM N KENTUCKY TO THE SE KENTUCKY PROJECT, ACCORDING TO BOARDWALK PIPELINE CO. IN OWENSBERG, KY. A TAKE OR PAY CONTRACT WOULD SUPPORT THE FINANCING AND ASSURE A LOWER PRICE OF GAS FOR THE PROJECT.

    20) THE CHATTANOOGA PROCESS WAS SUCCESSFULLY DEMONSTRATED AT ITS PILOT PLANT AT THE NATIONAL CENTRE FOR UPGRADING TECHNOLOGY (NCUT) IN DEVON, AB, CANADA.

    21) A LARGER “DEMONSTRATION” SCALE PLANT POTENTIALLY TO BE BUILT AND INTEGRATED INTO THE CENTER FOR APPLIED ENERGY RESEARCH (CAER) AT THE UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY IN LEXINGTON IS BEING REVIEWED. THE PLANT WOULD FURTHER VALIDATE THE SUCCESS OF THE DEVON PILOT PLANT IN LESS THAN 18 MONTHS.

    22) IN PARALLEL WITH THE OPERATION OF THE DEMO PLANT, COMMERCIAL FACILITIES IN THE NEW ALBANY DEPOSIT AREA COULD BE SITED AND ENGINEERED ON A FAST TRACK BASIS SO THAT THE FIRST COMMERCIAL FACILITY COULD BE COMPLETED BY 2014.

    For more information contact:

    Martin Karpenski
    President & CEO Chattanooga Corp
    26 East Madison Avenue
    Florham Park, NJ 07932
    973-377-1848 (office)
    973-342-1346 (mobile)
    973-377-2443 (fax)
    mkarpenski@aol.com

    Revised August 23, 2010

  • Gordonscott

    Hi Jeff I thought Tar was created by man? Why do you keep calling them Tar Sands?

  • Denny

    In contrast, what has the United States done with the Hirsch report? It seems that we are caught in a vicious cycle of economic intervention through historically low interest rates and stimulus spending with the goal of adding much needed jobs. However, if these problematic policies do succeed, more oil will be burned because no scaleable transportation alternatives exist. Meanwhile, China simultaneously restricts imports of the essential elements necessary for wind turbines, batteries, and solar and warily holds massive amounts of United States government debt. Can the United States really be considered a superpower when it doesn't control its energy or economic destiny?

  • Rogermoore55

    The thing I can't get my head around is that maybe 1 person in a 100 here in the USA seems to understand peak oil and its implications or that this recession isn't going away anytime soon. I'm talking everyone from the scientists to the doctors to your neighbor. Dirty dark Dick Cheney certainly understood peak oil, but I often wonder if anyone in our current government has a clue that our world has to get “a whole lot smaller”. If so, I truly wonder what advantage there is for our corporate masters to maintain silence on this and direct the media and the politicians away from any substantial discussion of peak oil? After all, must they not also transition into a new energy paradigm?

  • rojelio

    When, Jeff, does this hammer come down? As dreadful as peak oil will likely be, I choose to cuddle my teddy bear with happy thoughts along the lines of Ray Kurzweil's “the singularity is near”. I guess this falls into the “technology will magically save us” group of thinkers. The idea is that technology moves slow at first, but develops exponentially such that in certain areas, like computers and DNA sequencing, we've finally gotten to a level that we can't even imagine the amazing new paradigms that will unfold from one year to the next. Too bad this doesn't really explain why we still have to move stuff around with good old fashioned 19th century bunker oil and rape the ecosystem while we're at it.

  • Goneclimbing

    Jeff, I think you have to be careful with your statistics.
    You say the US oil consumption is “miles below their pre-recession peaks”.
    Pre-recession may have been near 22 MMBBL/d, now they are at 19 MMBBL/d, since when is a 15% such a massive drop.

    Also, using the US consumption and ignoring the rest of the world is a weak argument since you've argued in your book and in your blog about the BRIC countries and middle east consumption going up….

    I'm not arguing with your conclusions, I just think you need to be careful to throw out statements that could be used to invalidate your arguments.

  • liquidsnake2010

    Sir, accepting peak oil as the authoritative decider of the fate of human society undermines mans attempts to be god, as governments and other institutions cannot defy natures changes.

    The USA is a masonic republic, it was founded by freemasons. Freemasons take their ideology from ancient egypts sun worshipping cults, which developed during the egyptian civilisation and migrated when egypt was finally destroyed by nature. These cults only care about ruling, not the subjects they rule.

    I think we get a choice to either rule ourselves or rule others, and every civilisation i have studied that has met a catastrophic collapse (easter island, Anasazi, Maya, Rome) all appear to have a highly centralised, self interested elite class who indulge in black arts to maintain their status. Each time this has happened, the civilisation gets smashed because people worship another person rather than their environment.

    Bizarrely, cutting down of trees and soil erosion is the recurring issue, gonna run your car on wood if the oil isnt available? No, but hemp can be used for fuel and would repair the soil. Its true and is suppressed because it destroys fossil fuel monopoly

  • liquidsnake2010

    What i would also add to your comment sir, is that china has 900 million peasants, who could grow hemp as a local resource, or send it to the centre for use as a transport fuel.That would give the chinese all the fossil resources, massive renewable natural resources and massive resiliency to shocks. China could do this and not upset any trading partners, yet obtain massive strength because of it. Wise culture.